Thursday, September 5, 2013
Review: The Middle Kingdom by David Wingrove
Wingrove's world-building really takes off in this volume, with different levels in a very segmented society explored cleverly. The character's are three-dimensional, complex and engaging and the plot is well paced throughout.
I do have some small criticisms however. At this point in the series hundreds of years have passed where everything but distinctly Chinese culture and history have been suppressed and destroyed. However the world views between the European and Chinese characters still appear to be remarkably different and this is highly unrealistic. Also the industrialists never seem to realize that by taking on the T'ang however covertly they would be prime suspects and subject to a backlash. Again this seems highly improbable.
Overall solid world-building and characters make for a compelling read though a few story-telling mistakes ensure this is a very good book instead of the great one it could have been. 7.5/10.
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Since this is a republishing/repacking of a series written in late 80s to mid 90s, does this cause the book to feel dated??ReplyDelete
No, not at all. The first two books in the relaunched series were completely new. I haven't read the original release Middle Kingdom so I can't compare the two or assess how much was rewritten recently but at no point did it feel dated.ReplyDelete